Vocal Health – Part 3: Scope Out Your Problems … Need Surgery? Finding Doctors … Beware Side Effects, by Elizabeth Holmes

VOCAL HEALTH – Part 3
Scope Out Your Problems … Need Surgery?
Finding Doctors … Beware Side Effects 

By
Elizabeth Holmes

Voice Actor & VOXtra Staff Editor 
See Part 1
See Part 2

Years ago, I had
the privilege of attending a friend’s birthday party where Ella Fitzgerald
provided the evening’s entertainment. She was nearly 70 years old at the time, and her voice was still
magnificent.  

What are the odds
that your voice will still be going
strong in your later years? Much depends on how you take care of it now.

 

“If I could give
two pieces of advice to voice talent,” says Dr. Reena Gupta, director of the
Voice & Swallowing Center at Osborne Head & Neck Institute in Los
Angeles, “they would be: one, get a baseline exam from a qualified laryngologist
as early in your career as possible, and two, invest in your voice.”

 

Dr. Gupta
(pictured) specializes in caring for professional voices. And her passion for medicine is matched by her love of vocal arts.

In addition to Board Certifications in otolaryngology (ear, nose, throat – ENT) and laryngology, Dr. Gupta’s
professional credentials include a prestigious Fellowship in Laryngology and
Care of the Professional Voice (under the guidance of world-renowned voice
specialist Dr. Robert Thayer Sataloff). 

She has extensive experience in managing a wide variety of complex voice
disorders. 

 

VOICE EVALUATION – NOT ENT

“People think going
to an ENT is an appropriate way to have your voice evaluated,” Dr. Gupta
explains. “It’s not. Many ENTs don’t get enough voice
training. 

“The average amount of voice
training a doctor receives in five years of residency is three months,” she explains. “Sometimes it’s only one week!” 

 

So, what’s the
difference between having your voice evaluated, and a standard ENT exam?  

“In my opinion,”
says Dr. Gupta, “a proper voice evaluation must include stroboscopy, not just a
standard scope [flexible
laryngoscope].  

WHAT’S THE DIFFERENCE?

“A standard scope is the flexible scope that
passes through your nose; this catches about 10% and gives a gross
overview,” Dr. Gupta explains.

“Stroboscopy is a rigid scope
that passes through your mouth, and provides the illumination, resolution and
slow motion that’s needed to give a proper view of all structures,  as well as correctly identify problems such
as masses and polyps.” 

 

Flexible
laryngoscopy does not provide the illumination and resolution of
stroboscopy, she adds. Without that added
information, ENTs often struggle to explain a voice user’s problem. 

ACID REFLUX OFTEN BLAMED

Acid reflux is an easy explanation that has
become the “go-to diagnosis” for ENTs, and which often results in treatment for
acid reflux.  Of course, sometimes
swelling actually is caused by acid
reflux. 

“Good abdominal support is
important for vocal performance, and all that pressure can cause stomach acid
to be squeezed up,” Dr. Gupta notes.

“But there are other
reasons for hoarseness – and without stroboscopy, it’s extremely difficult to
correctly identify them.”

 

SCREAM AT YOUR PERIL

What vocal health issues are most often seen by Dr. Gupta?

“The most common
problems I see among voice actors are injuries from screaming and
shouting,” she says. “Nine times out of ten, it’s
from doing video games and animation. 

“That kind of work is often very challenging and taxing to the
voice. Sometimes,” she warns, “it can cause
irreversible damage.”

 

IF YOU NEED SURGERY …

Any advice for
voice actors undergoing surgery? 

 

“It’s not
specific to voice actors, but anyone undergoing an operation that involves a
general anesthetic needs to know the risks to their vocal health,” says Dr.
Gupta. 

“You’re dependent on the skill
of your anesthesiologist.  That doctor
needs to know how to place a tube down your throat properly.

“Also, the longer the procedure, the greater
the risk to your vocal health. You’ll
have swelling, and you’ll need to plan for a period of complete vocal rest afterward. 

“And be sure to get checked for pre-existing conditions that could
cause complications,” she adds. “If you have a
consultation with a skilled laryngologist before your operation, you’ll be
prepared for unexpected outcomes. Thyroid surgery and cervical spinal procedures, in particular, are risky
for vocal pros.”

  

TO FIND A DOCTOR …

So, how do you find a doctor who can help you
get the medical care you need? 

Vocal
coach Bettye Zoller recommends:

 

Look for board-certified
physicians. Common areas of
expertise include:

  • Laryngology (voice)  This certification requires an extra
    year of training, and focuses on vocal issues.
  • Otolaryngology (ear, nose, throat)
  • FACS (surgery)

     

Look for physicians who have experience
with voice professionals:

  • Experience with other vocal performers
    is helpful, but voice professionals do not have the same challenges as singers, on-stage actors and
    orators.  
  • Doctors with patients who
    do what you do.

     

Look for doctors who provide a timely,
attentive response:

  • When you’re sick, you need help in a
    hurry! The sooner you get attention, the
    sooner you’ll be back to work.
  • Make sure your doctor takes enough
    time to examine you thoroughly. Plan on an hour, the first time you go.

Also, Dr. Gupta has
graciously agreed to assist VoiceOverXtra readers find physicians specializing
in voice evaluations in their own parts of the country. Contact her
through:  www.ohni.org/contact.php.

 

Also check out www.ohniww.org
for more information on vocal health topics.

BE AWARE OF SIDE EFFECTS

When consulting
physicians for other health issues, be sure to know how potential drug side
effects may impact your vocal health. 

Dr. Kenneth W. Altman, Director of the Eugen Grabscheid MD Voice Center,
and Associate Professor of Otolaryngology at Mount Sinai School of Medicine in
New York City cautions:

“Medications can have unintended side effects on your
larynx. These include medications
prescribed by your doctor, over-the-counter preparations, and
homeopathic/herbal remedies.” 

Dr. Altman
suggests paying particular attention to the following:

 

Medications that may dry your vocal folds,
including:

 

  • Antidepressants
  • Muscle
    relaxants
  • Decongestants
  • Diuretics
  • Antihypertensives
  • Antihistamines
  • Anticholinergics
  • High-dose
    Vitamin C (greater than five grams per day)

     

Other medications that may affect your voice
include:

 

  • Angiotensin-converting-enzyme (ACE) inhibitors. Up to 10% of patients using this
    class of medications

    have
    problems with coughs and throat clearing.

  • Oral
    contraceptives. Estrogen
    in these may cause fluid retention (edema) in vocal folds.
  • Estrogen
    replacement therapy (post-menopause). Variable effects.
  • Thyroid
    replacement medication.

    If
    you have hypothyroidism, make sure your dose is sufficient.

  • Anticoagulants.

    If
    you develop polyps in response to trauma, they may bleed. 

STAY IN SHAPE!

The topic of vocal
health could easily occupy a book, but we hope this series of articles has
helped you to gain some practical tips for staying in shape (Part 1), raised your awareness about the
importance of taking timely action to treat problems (Part 2), and presented useful information about working successfully with you own doctor to keep
your voice in great shape (this article). 

 

With proper care,
you may end up giving Ella a run for her money! 

ABOUT
ELIZABETH …

 

Author Elizabeth Holmes is a voice actor, writer and audiobook narrator based in Healdsburg, CA.
She is also editor of VoiceOverXtra’s eBook division.

Email: Elizabeth@HolmesVoice.com

Web: www.HolmesVoice.com

  

Similar Posts

2 Comments

  1. What an excellent series of articles! Thank you for taking the time to research and interview the professionals and then craft it into a cohesive reading. And, a special “thank you” to Dr. Gupta for volunteering to help find specialized pro’s to help with vocal health! Good job, Elizabeth; these three are keepers, for sure!

  2. Elizabeth,

    With great interest, I read your Vocal Health series. Your writings prompted my response, beyond appreciation, for two other reasons:

    One is, I think I’ve finally beat a nagging mouth click problem I’ve always had (mostly successful editing them out but not always). Not wet sounds, not dry sounds nor pops: clicks. It came from a certain tense-ness I’d bring to the mic. Not nervousness but a certain kind of mouth/throat constriction. I recently had a few unrelated sessions with a personal trainer at my gym who stretched me out in ways I couldn’t have imagined. When we went as far as we thought we could go, I’d find ‘a place in my head’ to relax further, and deeper relaxation set in. I could go on, but wanted to offer, from a health POV, that in care for the total body, benefits for the voice can be realized. The relaxation I now bring to the mic – that loss of tension – all but made those clicks disappear.

    Then, separately, a dear friend (not in voice work) has been going through a hell I couldn’t have imagined. She was misdiagnosed three times for having lost her ability to speak: first, Bell’s Palsey; TIA’s (some mini-strokes!); tumor; then finally a non-malignant mass on her brain. Sub-standard medical attention aside, one must wonder, if one’s livelihood depends on talking and events like this happen, what’s your Plan B?

    Best regards, Ken Karp

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *