Income/Fees: Another Way To Figure Broadcast And New Media Voice Over Rates – Consider The Context, by J. Michael Collins
VOICE OVER RATES
Another Way To Figure Broadcast And New
Media Voice Over Rates: Consider The Context
June 22, 2015
By J. Michael Collins
Voice Actor & Coach
There
is a lot of money in political campaigns. At the national level, this
can amount to many hundreds of millions of dollars for a single
candidate. Some is well spent, while much is wasted in pursuit of
vainglorious ambitions that exceed public buy-in.
Embedded
within the political process, however, are a low-profile group of
individuals whose presence on a campaign can often make or break the
candidate’s chance for success.
These people often have vague titles
like “media adviser,” “consultant,” or “strategist.” Ultimately, they
are a highly-skilled group of fixers who can make the most mundane
aspirant look electric, and the most scandal-ridden seem virtuous.
These
operatives who add tremendous value to a political campaign have one
thing in common: While they may draw a fixed salary over the length of
the race, they make their real money based directly on the added value
they provide, as measured by the media buy of the campaign. The better
job they do, the more contributions a candidate receives, and the more
money the campaign has to spend on advertising – a small but
significant percentage of which goes into their pocket.
AND FOR VOICE OVER RATES …
There
has been fiery debate recently about broadcast and new media rate
structures in the voice over business.
A perception exists that rates are
being pushed lower by talent influx and changing technology.
Discussions both civil and acrimonious have generally boiled down to a
broad consensus that buyouts are bad, and residual pricing based on
usage is good.
- Is
it possible, however, that we may be missing the point altogether? - Is
there a fairer and more accurate means of determining appropriate
broadcast and new media rate structures that accounts precisely for the
value our services have added to a project? - Can a $150 TV buyout on an
online casting site actually be more fair than a national spot at double
union scale with residuals?
This author believes the answer is yes to all three questions.
NATIONAL BROADCAST RATES
Consider
this: The cost of a 13-week national broadcast run for a major brand
commercial can run into the millions of dollars.
With TV, maybe some cut
downs for radio, and Internet pre-roll/social media ads, let’s say a
major McBurger joint might spend $2M on the ad buy alone.
Union
scale for such an ad might amount to around $4K for the various media
for a single cycle. This represents one fifth of one percent of the
total ad buy into the pocket of the single individual chosen by the
company to give voice to their message.
Does that seem fair?
LAUGHABLE – OR FAIR?
During
a recent coaching session with a talent I am mentoring, we had a browse
through job postings on a particular online casting platform.
We
encountered a TV ad for a nursing organization to run for one month in a
single market of maybe 50,000 people in upstate New York. Pay? $150.
Now, both of us initially reacted the same way: $150 for TV? That’s
laughable!
Then a little light bulb went on. What might this particular group be spending to air this project?
Maybe…..maybe…..$2,500?
That might be a high estimate considering the market, but let’s go with
it. TV only, 4-week buy, small local market, $2,500.
So, at $150 all-in,
the talent receives 6% of the media buy.
If
the talent working for the McBurger company were to receive the same,
their pay for the gig would be $120,000 for a single cycle.
Which one seems more fair now?
NEW WAY TO FIGURE
It
is entirely possible that the debate over rates, online casting, union
versus non-union, etc., has completely missed the point.
While blanket
buyouts are clearly exploitative, especially for large brands, the cycle
and usage structures the industry has long relied upon are only a
degree less abusive. We are still signing away tremendous added value
for a pittance of what we actually contribute to the success of the
campaign.
Perhaps there is a third way.
Broadcast
and new media jobs should be considered in context, not based on
holy-writ numbers negotiated in back rooms or dreamed up by
entrepreneurs, the majority of which tend to be exceedingly favorable to
the buyer.
WORKS FOR NEW MEDIA
This
third way paradigm applies particularly well to new media like Internet
pre-roll, YouTube ads, and social media advertising.
Tracking usage and
impressions is cumbersome if it is possible at all. Tracking the media
buy is much more accessible, and a far better barometer of the value we
are adding.
A medium to large social media ad campaign might cost
$50,000 for instance. While the 6% figure presented in the
small market spot example is probably a bit ambitious, one could argue
that a minimum session fee plus 3% of the total ad buy would
be a fair rate for any broadcast or new media run.
For
our social media campaign, that might mean $250 + $1,500 for usage.
For
McBurger, a flat $60,000 – and for our nurses in Utica? That $150
suddenly looks a bit more reasonable.
These
days, it’s not often that we look to politics for good ideas. The great
rate debate will not abate any more than poor alliteration.
Nevertheless, perhaps this third way offers promise to bring order to
the chaos.
——————————
ABOUT J. MICHAEL
With almost 20 years as a professional voice over artist, J. Michael Collins has
worked with many major world companies, brands, sports leagues, and
organizations. In addition to his work in the classic,
agency-based world of voice over, he has
established himself as a leading P2P (pay-to-play, online casting) authority. He is a top-grossing
talent in the online marketplace, and also a voice talent coach and demo producer
Email: jmichael@jmcvoiceover.com
Web: www.jmcvoiceover.com
